The Old Fashioned is not just another drink on a menu. It is the foundation of modern mixology, a roadmap from which generations of bartenders have constructed and reimagined the craft.
The tale begins in 1806, when an upstate New York newspaper, The Balance and Columbian Repository printed what is thought to be the first definition of a cocktail: a stimulating liquor composed of spirits of any kind, sugar, water and bitters. This simple mixture would become known as the Whiskey Cocktail, a strong but straightforward drink that helped lay the foundation for bartending.
For decades, the formula remained pretty simple. However, in the second half of the 19th century bartenders began experimenting with new ingredients, techniques and the original Whiskey Cocktail started to evolve. Absinthe, curaçao and maraschino liqueur were among the ingredients finding their way into the glass. Those who preferred the original combination started asking for an old-fashioned whiskey cocktail. Eventually, the name stuck giving us the drink we know today.
The Old Fashioned is also closely tied to the history of the Pendennis Club in Louisville, Kentucky. Cocktail lore has it that the club popularized a version of the drink in the 1880s, supposedly created by bartender Martin Cuneo for Colonel James E. Pepper a prominent bourbon distiller. Pepper reportedly brought the recipe to New York, helping to popularize it. Its origins are still debated, but its connection to Kentucky bourbon remains a lasting element of its identity.
The Old Fashioned went through something of a dark age in the 20th century. Its original simplicity was often lost beneath aggressively muddled neon maraschino cherries, thick orange wedges and generous splashes of club soda. Somewhere along the way, a drink built around balance and restraint became an exercise in unnecessary additions.
Fortunately, the original formula was resurrected during the modern craft cocktail renaissance. Bartenders returned to quality whiskey, measured sweetness, aromatic bitters and controlled dilution, realizing that the beauty of the Old Fashioned lies in getting a handful of ingredients absolutely right.
Today, its flexibility is part of its enduring appeal. Its structure is so well balanced that it provides the perfect canvas for creative and technical expression. Modern interpretations might include homemade roasted pear syrup instead of simple syrup, dried cranberry-infused bitters, oak wood smoke or a finish of caramelized, dehydrated fruit.
These techniques can turn a familiar Woodford Reserve Old Fashioned into a multi-sensory experience without losing sight of what makes the original so special. The ingredients may change but the foundation remains the same: spirit, sweetness, bitters and dilution. That’s the beauty of the Old Fashioned. It doesn’t need to be reinvented to stay relevant. It simply needs to be understood.
Recipe:
60 ml good-quality bourbon or rye whiskey (e.g. Woodford Reserve)
5–10 ml simple syrup, according to taste
2–3 dashes of aromatic bitters
One large, clear ice cube
Orange peel, for garnish
Method
1. Add the simple syrup and aromatic bitters to a heavy-bottomed rocks glass.
2. Add the whiskey and a large, clear ice cube.
3. Stir gently and steadily until the drink is properly chilled and diluted to your liking, approximately 20–30 seconds, depending on the ice.
4. Cut a fresh piece of orange peel and express its oils over the surface of the drink.
5. Rub the rim of the glass with the peel and drop it into the drink as a garnish.
End of story.







No comments yet. Start the conversation.